Utility deal worth billions

Published Thursday October 29th, 2009

NB Power | Province to announce details of agreement with Hydro-Quebec

A1

Premiers Shawn Graham and Jean Charest will announce the details of a major power deal with Hydro-Quebec this morning.

Click to Enlarge
Stephen MacGillivray Photo
Premier Shawn Graham says New Brunswickers will find out about a deal with Hydro-Quebec today.

There are still no official details on the agreement, although The Canadian Press is reporting Quebec is about to buy a majority stake in NB Power.

The memorandum of understanding, if agreed to, would see Hydro-Quebec shell out just under $5 billion in cash - an amount equal to NB Power's debt - while a lower rate structure for electricity would see savings for New Brunswickers of approximately $5 billion, according to The Canadian Press.

"There is still a lot of talk around the discussions we've had with Hydro-Quebec and NB Power and the province of New Brunswick and the province of Quebec," said Graham on Wednesday after the annual Order of New Brunswick ceremony in Fredericton.

The premier has said any agreement would have to address several demands, such as lowering power rates for New Brunswickers, eliminating the utility's $4.7-billion debt, and promoting his government's vision of making New Brunswick a conduit for neighbouring provinces to export their energy to the northeastern United States.

The media conference is scheduled for 11 a.m. at Government House. Hydro-Quebec CEO Thierry Vandal and NB Power CEO David Hay will take part in the announcement.

Meanwhile, the premiers of Nova Scotia and Newfoundland and the union representing NB Power workers are all sending out warning signals about the deal.

Ross Galbraith, business manager for the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers Local 37, which represents 2,200 of NB Power's 2,600 employees, said Wednesday he's concerned about how any deal with Hydro-Quebec will affect workers here.

"I think we should be involved in any discussions," he told The Daily Gleaner. "We would like a seat at the table.

"It is pretty clear that discussions are occurring at high levels."

Galbraith said NB Power workers have good paying jobs that are important to all parts of the province.

He said he's concerned how a deal will affect those jobs, pensions and benefits, and terms and conditions of employment.

"It has all been speculation so far.''

He said Graham has referred to a memo of understanding being worked on. There would be a lot of work to do after such a memo, said Galbraith.

He said the last time a provincial utility changed hands was in the mid-1990s when Nova Scotia sold its power company to Emira.

"There were some (work force) reductions," said Galbraith. "They have had a reduction of reliability in that province.

"When we have severe weather, we hear news reports of the power being out in Nova Scotia more frequently than it is in this province."

Nova Scotia Premier Darrell Dexter issued a statement Wednesday, saying he's concerned that a deal to sell NB Power would harm Maritime co-operation.

"There is a difference between promoting Maritime interests and selling Maritime interests," Dexter said.

"Obviously, anything that removes anything as major as the ability to co-operate on energy policy from the equation should be a concern to everybody in this region.''

The Nova Scotia premier said he planned to talk to the premier of Quebec about it.

Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams on Wednesday released a letter responding to a letter Graham had sent him Tuesday about the deal.

"I am disappointed that our province was unaware of the depth of your negotiations with Hydro-Quebec given that sometime ago our energy corporation, Nalcor Energy, commenced good faith discussions with New Brunswick Power on potential components related to the development of the Lower Churchill," stated Williams.

He reminded Graham of Newfoundland's long grievance with Quebec over development of the Upper Churchill hydroelectric project.

Williams has vowed to go to court or to the federal competition bureau to try to block any deal that gives control of NB Power to Hydro-Quebec.

"I caution you based on our experience with Hydro-Quebec that a short-term opportunity can turn into a long-term loss of significant magnitude as they will most definitely find ways to recoup their investment and more from New Brunswickers who no longer control their energy destiny," said Williams.

"I have great fears and reservations about the stranglehold that Hydro-Quebec could put in place over the Atlantic region and I hope that you share this concern given your extensive statements on your desire to see your province as an energy hub.''

 

Comments (41)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Big rate cuts for big business, and nothing for everyday folks.

In politics, you have to dance with the one who brung ya. I guess we all know now who brought Shawn Graham to the dance.
100
Thumbs Up
22
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
John McLane, Nashwaaksis on 29/10/09 06:43:32 AM AST
Ummm... what happened to self-sufficiency Mr. Graham?
Well played Mr. Irving.
I'm heading west.
102
Thumbs Up
19
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Just a_thought, Fredericton on 29/10/09 07:01:06 AM AST
This comment has been removed due to a violation of canadaeast.com's Terms of Use, Section F. Interactive Features. Click here to review the Terms of Use.
N. PRIEST, HALIFAX on 29/10/09 07:09:28 AM AST
makes me nervous... but then again leaving it (NBPower) in the hands of the people who ran up massive debts because of cost overruns and ficticious fuel supplies also make me nervous....
80
Thumbs Up
10
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Simple Man, Fredericton on 29/10/09 07:12:55 AM AST
This deal is fantastic for all NBers. Rates are expected to go up 20 percent in next few years and now we get a freeze for 5 years and indexed after. This is a huge savings and secures us cheap rates. 5 billion in sacvings by this occurring. This is huge. We will aso get our debt paid off and this aa=ccounts for another 5 billion, this is huge . Now our children will not have to be responsible for the debts we ran up. This is a once in a lifetime chance, I am a happy New Brunswicker
53
Thumbs Up
132
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Ideas Everywhere, Fredericton on 29/10/09 07:29:02 AM AST
Ah Ideas Everywhere I hope you are being a tad bit sarcastic.... No one in their right mind would actually want their child to take on the burden of enormous debt.
41
Thumbs Up
22
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader, fredericton on 29/10/09 07:50:50 AM AST
If Mr. Williams is so concerned about NB then show us the money! I sure you have a big reserve of oil money that you would love to share with your maritime buddies. Mr Dexter should chose his words wisely other wise we may just have to renegotiate his natural gas pipeline that runs through our province for which we receive no royalties.

This is a great day for New Brunswickers! Too bad there are some out there who would rather take advantage of us than to just say good job neighbor.
42
Thumbs Up
68
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader , Fredericton on 29/10/09 07:55:37 AM AST
But when we call their customer service lines will we get service in English, or must we first talk to someone in French?

Just become some shady guy dressed in a trench coat standing in a dark alley offers to bail you out, doesn't meant it's a deal of a lifetime.
73
Thumbs Up
45
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anon Nimity, Fredericton on 29/10/09 08:04:01 AM AST
No government of NB has a mandate to sell off assets owned by the people of NB without first receiving permission via a plebiscite. All of this should not be sprung on the people in this manner. It should have been well discussed before any "memorandum of understanding" is/was signed. What were we the owners of NBP able to "understand" without any knowledge of this behind our backs scheme. NBP is the "only" thing NB has to call our own. When we lose control of NBP we will truly be a have not province. This government is selling us out and if possible a court injunction should be issued to stop this from going any further until it is fully, publicly discussed and voted on by the people of this fast fading province.
90
Thumbs Up
15
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
the thenkare, Greater Fredericton Area on 29/10/09 08:28:21 AM AST
you need to start with some sort of agreement between the two or it would be complete chaos. I'm not sure of what is in the deal, but it's nice to see some people are catching on to what Danny Millions is up to. He does not care about NB. He is only trying to leverage a better deal for his province.
38
Thumbs Up
21
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Mr K, Fred on 29/10/09 08:35:08 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles