Paying the price for 'excellence'

Published Wednesday March 19th, 2008
B1

Kevin Dickie says the tough decisions that were made in paring the varsity athletics program from 14 to eight teams are in line with the University of New Brunswick's goals to become known as a program of national stature.

Caption
UNB’S KEVIN DICKIE

"To become excellent, to meet our mission and to pay the bills of the day is not sustainable, (with 14 programs)," said the beleagured athletic director who has been taking the brunt of the criticism for the realignment of six programs from the school's varsity program into the competitive club system.

Dickie's interpretation of the changes, which involve the men's and women's wrestling programs; the men's swim team, the men's and women's cross country teams and the women's hockey program, is that two programs (cross country and wrestling) are affected minimally, one (men's and women's swimming) affected positively and one (women's hockey) affected drastically."

Dickie said the women's hockey program was the most expensive varsity sport on campus.

"It cost us over $110,000 to run women's hockey last year," he said. That doesn't include money for scholarships or hiring a full time coach, which Dickie estimates it would cost to make the program competitive with their Atlantic University Sport Women's Conference competition.

He said other AUS programs spend up to $70,000 on scholarships and are supplementing their competitive schedules against American competition.

"Do the math, and tell me what we would need to invest in order to get us into the competition."

And Dickie made it clear that the mandate of the university is to not just "get into" the competition, but to win.

He called the school's athletics program "a high performance environment. I've never, as a coach, even talked about winning," he said. "I've talked about performance. And if your performance meets the variables around you that give you a chance to have success, you should win.

"We haven't necessarily distributed the variables in the right place. We can redistribute what we have into programs that need it. We're not shortchanged," he said. "The university treats us extremely well. We're just trying to spread the money too thin."

The "reinvestment" of resources into the eight programs which remain is an effort to fix that.

He said the splitting of the men's and women's swim teams will allow the women access to funds under the varsity budget. The men's team will be required to raise scholarship monies as the men's hockey, men's volleyball and men's soccer programs have.

"Their success is in direct correlation to the scholarships they give," he said. "The scholarships they give are in direct correlation to their fund raising efforts as a team."

Dickie agrees with women's hockey coach Don Davis' philosophical approach to the role of the faculty of kinesiology.

"I think the university always has to have a role in terms of leadership," he said. "But not when it costs you $110,000 and when it would cost you that much more to do it right."

Dickie said the former varsity programs drain human as well as financial resources. Subtraction of varsity status will allow staff to devote more to varsity sports in such areas as community outreach, budget management, sports information and website communications, eligibility, travel, marketing, development fund raising and running day-to-day and specialty events.

Dickie refers to the University of British Columbia Thunderbirds, who have taken championship banners home from the last two national championship events at the Aitken Centre.

"Why can't that be my vision with the Varsity Reds?" he said.

He believes they're on the right track. On his system of "power ranking" of schools within the AUS, a personal scoring system which grades each school on several criteria, UNB improved from sixth in the 11-team Conference the year before to second only to the Cape Breton University Capers last year. It's all part of the plan to "helping us become a national institution," he said.

He said the mission of the varsity program is "to be excellent in athletics, excellent in academics and excellent in the community...excellence being defined as the best that we can be."

He said university president Dr. John McLaughlin shares that vision, pointing to the establishment of a $50,000 "championship fund" ; a "matching" program in which the university will match donor donations to establish scholarships to the tune of $250,000 over three years; and the establishment of 13 "Residence Life" scholarships over the past two years.

"But what they're saying "We need a return on our investment, based on the mission, the vision and the values of our university."

Athletically, that means UNB has to "get to the next level, and we need to be front and centre," said Dickie. "We need to be a place of destination for kids across the country. We need to be a place where kids want to be for varsity athletics."

Dickie bought into that vision when he was hired as athletic director three years ago. It was the vision he brought to his job interview.

"That was the whole premise of my interview, the whole premise of my presentation and the premise of me ensuring before I signed on the dotted line that the opportunity would be there for us to be the best we could be." he said. "It was based on the premise of Dr. McLaughlin's vision for the university, which I very much subscribe to. If that wasn't the premise, I'm not the athletic director here. There's never been a day when I have strived to be a part of anything other than the best I and we can be. Fortunately, I walked into an environment that was going to allow that to happen."

Over the long term, Dickie believes it will be the right step.

"My whole life has been about trying to do the right thing," he said.

"I wake up every day trying to make a positive difference. And I really believe this will be a part of that. Unfortunately, for the short term, it's certainly had a negative impact on some people. There hasn't been an e-mail or a phone call or a message on my answering machine that I haven't answered. There's a saying that goes something like 'Don't judge a person by what they do, judge a person by what they do with what they have.' That's been a foundation of everything that has transpired here since last week."

Please Log In or Register FREE

You are currently not logged into this site. Please log in or register for a FREE ONE Account.
Logged in visitors may comment on articles, enter contests, manage home delivery holds and much more online. Your ONE Account grants you access to features and content across the entire CanadaEast Network of sites.

Comments (7)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

I hear he's planning on bringing back football...guess the money for a team like that has to come at the expense of others. I honestly can't see the women's hockey team costing more then $100000. They get $100 each for sticks compared to $1000+ for the mens team. This man is going to kill athletics at unb!
6
Thumbs Up
6
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 19/03/08, 8:19:34 AM ADT
First of all I would like to say that is anyone actually attended a womens hockey game they would realize how there are about 20 fans in the stands.....and there it has free adminssion to the game. Second of all why would UNB give more then 100 bucks to the girls for sticks???..they never break them...the men break their sticks all the time they need that extra $$.
I find it silly how everyone is making such a big deal out of this when there isn't any support for the team during the season. If more people were to attend the games....and trust me there were no more then 20 people there because I was one of the people in the stands.....then maybe the hokey team wouldn't be in this situation
I don't doubt it at all that it cost 110 000 last year....think about all the travel expenses, the equiipment, the hotes, the buses, the staffing, the ice time, the people that make a hockey event possible....they all need to be paid...think about how much UNB spend just on the refs alone

6
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 19/03/08, 9:18:13 AM ADT
I think people are overlooking the fact that Kevin didn't just make this desicion over night, nor did he make it alone. I think he went about it the wrong way telling people however in his shoes would you do any different? Look at the reaction from everyone attacking, and calling him down....he wasn't alone in this decision and who gives everyone including the papers to degrade his name.

I think this is really bringing out many childish behaviours in people.
8
Thumbs Up
5
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 19/03/08, 9:22:12 AM ADT
If hockey is important to UNB and achieving excellence is the goal, should not the young women who play and represent UNB not have the same opportunity? The name calling is childish, I agree, but let's look at who are truly effected by this decision. These women that have never seen a scholarship, had to purchase their own jerseys and certainly were not marketed at all compared to the men's team. It has taken a couple of lifetimes to bring the Men's program to excellence. We are certainly very proud of their achievements. But, if you have reached the highest level, where else is there to go? Is it not about maintenance from here on in? The bottom line is that you cannot discriminate on who has the right to achieve and who does not. With only 6 years as a varsity level women's sport and no one coming up through the University as a female hockey player, your investment from Alumni is minimal for scholarships. The equation is all wrong.
6
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 19/03/08, 2:22:29 PM ADT
Conversation between a mother tand daughter,

"I'm sorry honey, there is no future for you in hockey................please go hang up your skates now and put on your apron, Dear."
4
Thumbs Up
13
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 19/03/08, 3:15:16 PM ADT
Mr. Dickie quoted as saying

"He said other AUS programs spend up to $70,000 on scholarships and are supplementing their competitive schedules against American competition."

Has he ever heard of Title XI? The American Law stating that all athletes (regardless of gender, race, stature) are to be granted full access to funding within the University system without regard. How about the recent ruling from the University of Saskatchewan? We may think the American's have their issues, but at least they protect all athletes from underhandedness. Dynasties do have a tendency to fall.

Check it out at http://www.american.edu/sadker/titleix.htm


6
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 19/03/08, 3:40:42 PM ADT
Why are we blaming the messenger? Let's face it....a decision like this does not come from Mr. Dickie, this comes from higher up the ladder.

Secondly, why is everyone fighting over this issue, I know all the sports are near and dear to all the athletes, however instead of fighting why not put your efforts into getting a team together to compete in the senior league around Freddy? There is nothing anyone can do to change the decision...so why the big fuss, take what you have and make the best out of it....why make a crappy situation worse?
7
Thumbs Up
5
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Anonymous Reader on 19/03/08, 4:44:03 PM ADT
Advertisement

Search Articles