Train station salvation?

Published Saturday March 14th, 2009

Source | NB Liquor could open new store on historic property

A1

NB Liquor could give new life to Fredericton's abandoned train station.

Click to Enlarge
The Daily Gleaner/James West Pho
RUNDOWN: Above is the old train station on York Street in Fredericton. A well-placed source has told The Daily Gleaner that NB Liquor may be eyeing the property for a new store location.

The Daily Gleaner has learned that government officials are having the Crown corporation look into the possibility of opening a new liquor store at the site as part of a revitalization of the property.

Sources say any decision on the project is at least six months away.

"They're just looking at it right now," said one well-placed insider. "But there has to be a business case for it."

The provincial liquor corporation has no plans in hand to do so, but it isn't dismissing the possibility.

"We do not have a proposal in front of us or on the table with regards to the downtown train station. It's something we'd be prepared to look at if it fit into our plan," said Nora Lacey, manager of communications for NB Liquor.

Lacey said the liquor corporation would need to have a budget for the project approved by its board of directors.

"There's nothing formal in front of us. We'd all like to see something done with the train station, for sure, (as it's) such a historic landmark in our city," she said.

The train station property has been the cause of community consternation for some time in the capital.

Built in 1923, it's protected under federal heritage legislation that bars owners J.D. Irving Ltd. from tearing it down.

The cost of rehabilitating the historic structure has been pegged at up to $2 million. The company has said it isn't feasible to do that work without a major development in the area.

Rehabilitation of the former train station building is a requirement for development of the surrounding land.

The opening of a new downtown liquor store would mark something of an about-face for the liquor corporation.

The Crown corporation faced a barrage of criticism when it closed the King Street liquor store Jan. 26, 2008.

Many said the decision was short-sighted, given the level of tourism and convention activity in the downtown.

Lacey said any new foray into the area would have to be assessed on a business level first.

J.D. Irving wants to redevelop the station as part of a commercial or office development along that area.

In recent years, company officials negotiated with developers, talked to prospective tenants and even signed a letter of sale after being offered $1, but so far nothing has materialized.

A redemption centre that sat adjacent to the train station, and which was considered an impediment to commercial development in the area, was torn down last year.

Liz Burge, president of the Fredericton Heritage Trust, said she hopes to see the train station revitalized.

"The Fredericton Heritage Trust is looking forward to seeing a train station development in context of development of the whole block of land," she said.

Officials with J. D. Irving had little comment on the matter.

"We continue to pursue opportunities for a site development that would enable the estimated $2-million restoration of the train station. For confidentiality reasons, we are unable to comment on any discussions with potential partners in a development project on the railway site," said company spokesman Geoff Britt.

 

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (13)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Just tear it down its a eye sore to the city of Fredericton... Its an unsafe building and I honnestly do not want a liquor store in my back yard...
21
Thumbs Up
52
Thumbs Down
Blue Blazer, Fredericton on 14/03/09 09:45:49 AM AST
Seems Blue Blazer has a bad case of NIMBY. If the restoration can proceed by the owner and NBLCC has a lease at the site as an anchor, add some local Artisans, it could be very well a start to see a rejuvenation of this area, which could also see the adjacent lots cleaned up and perhaps a combo of Business/Residential Development. Much better than Urban Sprawl. This would also enhance the surrounding areas to maybe see the owners clean up their back and front yards
33
Thumbs Up
8
Thumbs Down
B EAGLES, Fredericton on 14/03/09 11:21:40 AM AST
All we need is another Liquor Store in the city...downtown at that. More drunks to vandalize and disturb the downtown area. Great solution, NOT!
11
Thumbs Up
42
Thumbs Down
Anon Reader, Fredericton on 14/03/09 11:27:33 AM AST
"There has to be a business case for it". Are they kidding? NB Liquor could erect a liquor store at the deepest area of the frozen St. John River in January and "there would be a business case for it!!"
30
Thumbs Up
3
Thumbs Down
Lisa Deighan, Fredericton on 14/03/09 11:39:25 AM AST
Another ANBL folly! Government should not be in the business of booze sales! Taxpayers in the end will suck up the cost of an Irving responsibility. It is too late the building is finished.
16
Thumbs Up
19
Thumbs Down
D W, Fredericton on 14/03/09 12:04:30 PM AST
I heard this story this afternoon on the radio. I laughed because right after saying that the train station has been an eye sore for the past few years it happily said that there may be plans for a new liqour store there. So in other words, cost to bring the train station back to an acceptable state is an eye sore, another liquor store with the less fortunate and underage looking for people to buy liquor for them outside it, a promising solution. Yes... that does make sense.
9
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
s. all, fredericton on 14/03/09 01:49:40 PM AST
"if the responsibility of selling booze was taken out of the hands of the government, there is a pretty good chance private enterprise would make it unaffordable to the common man....except for swill that would peel paint off your car."

Thata makes no sense, propably the other way around. Why would a corner store price booze so no one could afford it, when you could go down the street and find someone who would not?
9
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
D W, Fredericton on 14/03/09 04:02:38 PM AST
Just tear the damn thing down and build a liquor store. The amount of money that would go into fixing it up would far surpass the cost of building a new store. The Irvings are just looking at any way possible to collect some rent money and move into the real estate business. I'm sure we'll soon see regular articles in the Irving Press saying what a great plan this will be for the city.
4
Thumbs Up
13
Thumbs Down
In Ptbo, New Brunswick on 14/03/09 04:30:51 PM AST
It is a shame that another historic land mark will "bite the dust"-either way,liquor store or demolition. Something should have been done when it was not in such a state of disrepair. Now the government wants to spend tax money on this for another government run business? When will it ever come to them that health care is far more important than another liquor store? Then they dare to put ads on TV stating where to get help if you have a drinking problem--go figure! Suppose they are part of this problem? We don't need a liquor store every mile or so apart. I suppose though,not all people drive vehicles!
8
Thumbs Up
1
Thumbs Down
G. Doherty, Minto on 15/03/09 03:26:28 PM AST
It would be a shame to tear down the building. There are few reminders in the city of the times past when the railroad was a going concern and trains were so familiar. The old building is in hard shape but I'm sure is repairable. And there must be better things than a liquor store that can make use of it. Aren't there enough business people in the city with vision for development to do something with the building and this whole area. Before the fence was put up I did a series of sketches of the deteriorating building, planning eventually to do a series of paintings. I also wrote a children's book focused on the old station, that I am trying to get published. This is part of our city's history and if there is a possibility of rebuilding it then it should be done now.
8
Thumbs Up
2
Thumbs Down
Forrest Long, Tuscaloosa on 15/03/09 05:27:53 PM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles