Premier promotes power partnership

Published Wednesday October 28th, 2009

Utilities | Talks on with Hydro-Quebec, memorandum of understanding expected

A1

Premier Shawn Graham says New Brunswick is making progress in its talks with Quebec about the future of NB Power.

But he didn't release more details about those talks Tuesday and he's asking the public not to jump to conclusions about a potential deal.

"What I am asking New Brunswickers today is before any preconceived decisions are made on their own, let us have an opportunity to explain to all New Brunswickers what a potential partnership could offer and also at the same time what the benefits are for New Brunswickers in the long term," said Graham.

"We are at a critical point in the discussion process," said the premier. "They have been progressing well.''

News of the talks broke last week although the Liberals announced in June that they were looking at ways to co-operate more with Hydro-Quebec.

Graham said there would be no final deal announced if the talks are successful.

"What we are looking at is a memorandum of understanding of where we can move forward from the discussions that have taken place to date.''

The premier wouldn't say when that might happen.

"There is all kinds of speculation out there," said Graham. "We are going to allow the process to unfold as it should."

He said the talks with Quebec are about getting lower power rates for New Brunswickers, creating jobs and dealing with NB Power's crippling $4.7-billion debt.

The premier also said the province wants to move ahead on making New Brunswick an energy hub.

"We've always stated that our geography is our greatest asset. Last year, we took a clear position as a government that we want to maximize our geographic location."

He promised there would be opportunities for New Brunswickers to discuss any agreement and be engaged in the process once the talks with Quebec are complete.

An article in The Globe and Mail newspaper Saturday reported that the potential deal is worth $10 billion and would see Hydro-Quebec take over key assets of NB Power.

According to the Globe, the deal would see Hydro-Quebec take over NB Power's $4.7-billion debt and provide $5 billion in savings to ratepayers.

In return, Hydro-Quebec would get greater access to the New Brunswick market and a transmission corridor to U.S. markets, stated the Globe.

Newfoundland Premier Danny Williams has already condemned the talks and threatened to take any deal to the federal competition bureau for review.

Graham released a letter he sent to Williams on Tuesday, saying New Brunswick was trying to grow its economy and move off the federal equalization program as Newfoundland has done with oil and gas developments.

"I was, therefore, shocked and saddened by statements you were reported to have made which suggested Newfoundland and Labrador would hinder the economic progress of New Brunswick," wrote Graham to Williams.

He promised that New Brunswick would remain open to Newfoundland electricity passing through the province to the U.S. market.

"Nor will we, in any way, surrender our sovereignty over energy policy," said Graham.

Meanwhile, Official Opposition Leader David Alward urged Graham to recall the legislature immediately and set up a special bipartisan committee to review the deal with Quebec.

The committee should also be able to hear opinions from energy experts on any agreement and lead an informed debate, he said.

"What New Brunswickers don't need is this government to come out immediately with a huge public relations exercise," said Alward.

Graham said he spoke to Alward on Sunday about the talks and that there is a role the official Opposition can play in the process.

The premier said he has no plans to call the legislature back into session before the scheduled Nov. 17 date.

 

Comments (19)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

Danny Williams hit the nail on the head when he said that the only one who will ultimately benefit from this deal will be hydro quebec. Any savings that NBers see in the immediate future will eventually be gone when HydroQuebec starts putting the screws to us. Our $4.7 billion debt won't just disappear rest assured HQ will want to recover what they invest.
70
Thumbs Up
14
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Goodbye Liberals2010, Fredericton on 28/10/09 08:17:07 AM AST
Have we asked this question??? If Quebec were to seperate from Canada what would happen then? I would never make any deals with Quebec because they never keep their promises. Remember Oka?????? don't be too quick to blame the Natives on that one - it was a case of this is what we will do and at the last minute the government changed the entire game plan. Why would we be creating more jobs if it was just taken over by another province? How many present jobs would be lost? I don't trust Shawn Graham and his merry group of men at all. How come we are not looking at Newfoundland - at least Danny Williams keeps his word? Why would we not benefit Newfoundland because they have been a struggling province just like us. Don't forget Quebec gets the lions share of equalization payments and as a province they are doing no better than we are. THIS IS SCARY.
69
Thumbs Up
13
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
N. PRIEST, HALIFAX on 28/10/09 08:26:35 AM AST
Exactly N. Priest! Why the heck would Hydro Quebec want to purchased a NEW BRUNSWICK company when they have always wanted to SEPERATE?!?!?!? There is obviously an underlying reason!
54
Thumbs Up
10
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Midland Community, NB on 28/10/09 08:34:58 AM AST
Who is making all the money putting this deal together. Liberals. Premier how much money are you making o this deal?
50
Thumbs Up
13
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
neighborhood watch, Fredericton on 28/10/09 08:37:41 AM AST
Pleaaase no. Why is this even a question? Isn't NFLD buying power back from them as we speak? It will save Irving $ and I think the Premier is setting himself up for a cushy Irving job once his term is over.
Please please no!
40
Thumbs Up
10
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
O. Media, fredericton on 28/10/09 09:11:43 AM AST
If NB power is so unprofitable, get rid of some of those big high priced political oppointments. Anyone who can't make money selling power smokes to much crack!
30
Thumbs Up
8
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Miramichi ExPat, Halifax on 28/10/09 09:48:18 AM AST
I fail to see why Danny Williams is protesting this, aside from his own province's interest in using NB's electrical grid to get access to New England markets. He conveniently forgets that PEI's provincial electrical utility, Maritime Electric Co., is owned by a Nfld company, Fortis, which was created as a holding company for the Nfld Light & Power Co.

Nfld taxpayers reap the benefits of corporate taxes placed on Fortis which earns a percentage of its profit from the guaranteed profit margin of Maritime Electric Co. as established under PEI regulations.

Islanders pay among the highest electrical rates in North America.

Again, so what if a utility in one province owns a utility in another? It already is the case with Fortis in Nfld owning Maritime Electric in PEI. It already is the case with Emera in Nova Scotia owning Bangor Hydro in Maine. And Fortis also owns Canadian Niagara Power and Cornwall Electric in Ontario.
12
Thumbs Up
28
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Ice Shimmer, Fredericton on 28/10/09 09:52:23 AM AST
I think Premier Shawn Graham is showing great leadership on this issue. We will be singing his praises for many years if we New Brunswickers can walk away from this mostly free of NB Power's debt. I'm one who thinks a technological revolution is coming very soon which will result in every home having its own personal generating unit. Better to sell now rather than being stuck with a huge debt and mostly redundant public utility assets.
10
Thumbs Up
36
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Peter Kincaid, Fredericton on 28/10/09 10:49:43 AM AST
Ice shimmer, the difference is we the people of NB will still control the power with NFLD only using our Transmission grid and paying us a levy for selling the power through our system, easy money quite honestly. Yes looks like Shawn Graham knows he is on the way out and is trying to set himself up a job for later, and NB Power does loose money due to political appointments from the government. Amazing deal to avoid, Quebec is not doing this out of the goodness of their hearts. Hard to be an energy Hub when you don't control the energy. Hydro Quebec only needs the Transmission lines, which NB'ers have sacrificed their lands to allow to pass for NB, not for Quebec. NB Power is not yours to sell Mr. Graham, its ours and you do not have the authority.
24
Thumbs Up
6
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Other Side, Fredericton on 28/10/09 11:01:47 AM AST
I can't comment on the relative merits of the present negotiations. However, I have no confidence in anything this govt. does any longer. It has a record of misinformation and replacing meaningful public consultation with stage managed events and political spin. It has failed consistently to be even remotely transparent and operates best in secrecy and obfuscation. It has as well a history of not fully considering either the short term of long term ramifications of its decisions and policies. This government is not trustworthy and would have a hard time successfully running a convenience store. So much for self-sufficiency. The fact is that this province is run by two families and their commercial concerns. This govt. like all of those the came before it are in the pocket of the oligarchs.
20
Thumbs Up
4
Thumbs Down
Flag as Inappropriate
Flag as Inappropriate
Sly One, New Maryland on 28/10/09 11:52:56 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles