Miles says agreement represents breath of fresh air

Published Thursday November 26th, 2009

Goodbye fossil fuels | Closure of two plants already announced

A1

The deal to sell NB Power to Hydro-Quebec will cut greenhouse gas emissions in this province by more than 10 per cent, says Environment Minister Rick Miles.

But the Opposition says the same thing could be achieved by purchasing more hydro power from Quebec.

"My staff at the Department of Environment has done extensive research and it's clear that the sale of NB Power will be a good thing for the environment in New Brunswick," said Miles on Wednesday.

"This proposed agreement would help us reduce the province's annual greenhouse gas emissions by 11 per cent," he said.

"These reductions will put us on track to meet or exceed the commitments made in the New Brunswick climate change action plan.''

The Graham government wants to sell most of the assets of NB Power to Hydro-Quebec for $4.75 billion - which will be used to pay off the utility's debt - and $5 billion in rate relief.

Under the proposed deal, Hydro-Quebec wouldn't buy NB Power's fossil fuel power plants such as Coleson Cove and Belledune and those facilities could be closed with one year's notice.

With or without the deal, the Grand Lake and Dalhousie power plants will be closed within a year.

Miles said New Brunswick will exceed its 2012 greenhouse gas emissions reduction target by one million tonnes due to the decommissioning of Grand Lake and Dalhousie.

He also said air quality in New Brunswick will be improved under the deal to sell NB Power.

"Mercury emissions will be below the 2010 Canada-wide standard for coal-fired power plants set for New Brunswick and will reach the high end of the reduction targets set by the New England governors and eastern Canadian premiers," said Miles.

Sulphur dioxide emissions will be more than two times lower than 2010 targets, he said.

When all of New Brunswick's carbon-based power plants are closed, the annual emissions of sulphur dioxide will be reduced by 33,000 tonnes, nitrogen oxide emissions will fall by 13,000 tonnes, volatile organic compounds will decrease by 6.5 tonnes and the annual emission of mercury will fall by 96 kilograms, said Miles.

"New Brunswick will also be better positioned to sell manufactured products into a lower carbon green economy, with products manufactured using less carbon intensive processes" he said.

"This is incredible news for our provinces and represents a brighter future for clean energy generation.''

But official Opposition Leader David Alward said all these goals could be achieved without selling NB Power.

"The same benefits could be achieved through a long-term purchase agreement with Quebec," he said.

 

Disabled

Commenting has been disabled for this item. Existing comments appear below but you may not add a new comment at this time.

Comments (28)

All comments are subject to the site Terms of Use. For a full commenting tutorial click here.

Our editorial team relies on filtering technology and our visitor community to identify inappropriate comments. In the event that a site user has submitted offensive content that has evaded our filter, please select the option to Flag As Inappropriate presented within the comment. Thank you for helping to keep this site clean.

"But the Opposition says the same thing could be achieved by purchasing more hydro power from Quebec."

Amusingly enough, that's exactly what the MOU has us do if power usage ever grows and we get past the heritage pool.

So, why didn't we just do that in the first place to fill in any gaps as we close the older plants? Whats the need in selling at all? (And no folks, don't try to argue the debt. The Auditor General already disproved that and that position carries a lot more weight then Premier Pinocchio.)
87
Thumbs Up
17
Thumbs Down
Chris Eaton, Fredericton on 26/11/09 06:59:58 AM AST
And while we're on the subject, Newfoundland wants to build another Churchhill Falls. They want to distribute that power to the US. We have a transmission network they need to do that.

Why don't we go in on that, and use the profits from transmitting the power to buy some of it?
85
Thumbs Up
10
Thumbs Down
Chris Eaton, Fredericton on 26/11/09 07:07:55 AM AST
Heard this morning on the news that Alward wants a referendum on the sale of NB Power. I think his chances of getting it are slim to none. I along with a lot of people are still on the fence waiting for Alward to inform the public of his plan with regard to NB Power. To say that he will not sell it is not really a plan to the people outlining how he would pay the debt down and continue to provide power at the current or at least a reasonable rate. If his plan is to increase the power rates in the high single digits or the low double digits, then the poor of the province will have to start burning wood not that many of them don't already. That will really help our green house emissions.
At any rate, over to you Mr. Alward for some words of wisdom
37
Thumbs Up
64
Thumbs Down
Wild Bill, Rusagonis on 26/11/09 07:09:57 AM AST
I'm glad to see the government finally promoting the environmental benefits of this deal. It makes sense to start transitioning to cleaner and renewable forms of power now, while we're still able and cost isn't a prohibitive factor.
26
Thumbs Up
87
Thumbs Down
Michel LeBlanc, Dieppe on 26/11/09 07:19:11 AM AST
"I along with a lot of people are still on the fence waiting for Alward to inform the public of his plan with regard to NB Power."

Personally, I don't care if the PCs have a plan at this point, as long as the sale is stopped. I would much prefer that they take their time in coming up with a solid plan that is workable and can be achieved, not one that sells out NB and will be devastating for NB like the one on the table now!
88
Thumbs Up
23
Thumbs Down
Common Man, Fredericton on 26/11/09 07:24:52 AM AST
We are going to sell our profitable energy generation plants and be stuck with the expensive closures of our less environmentally friendly generators.....I can see why Hydro Quebec only wanted the profitable plants and not Coulson Cove, Grand Lake or Belldune....Smart on their part...
66
Thumbs Up
9
Thumbs Down
taxpaying consumer, Moncton on 26/11/09 08:11:28 AM AST
The same benefits would not be achieved if we didn't sell NB Power. If we simply bought power from Hydro-Quebec and closed our plants, we would still have $4.8 billion in debt and we wouldn't have the same kind of rate relief. Developing other green power sources here in NB takes time and money we don't have. If we unload NB Power's debt, other green options become much more feasible.

In fact, this deal helps NB achieve lower emmissions more quickly. It also opens us up to future markets looking for clean, renewable energy like Hydro.
25
Thumbs Up
54
Thumbs Down
J Liz, NB on 26/11/09 08:32:39 AM AST
Mr Miles sure spins a tall tale. I think that the majority of New Brunswickers can see beyond all this misinformation that the Liberals are feeding us. Give us a break, we're not buying your b.s.!
49
Thumbs Up
11
Thumbs Down
dowereally needit, Fredericton on 26/11/09 10:14:24 AM AST
Sell sell sell!
6
Thumbs Up
57
Thumbs Down
Omemee With Love, Shh! on 26/11/09 10:20:42 AM AST
Wild Bill: I am not a conservative, but the burden does not fall on Mr. Alward to offer an alternative to a kooky plan. The burden on Mr. Alward is to do his best to represent the interests of New Brunswickers when the government gets out of hand. I would say that is the situation now. I don't give a flying monkey's kidney what his "alternative" is, I just want him to pressure the government to abandon what is clearly, painfully clearly, such a horrible deal for the future of this Province.
38
Thumbs Up
7
Thumbs Down
Henry Henry, Fredericton on 26/11/09 10:25:48 AM AST
Advertisement
Advertisement

Search Articles